Butler-Tarkington

Butler-Tarkington is one of Indianapolis’ most beloved historic neighborhoods — a tree-lined, architecturally rich community known for its welcoming character, cultural landmarks, and beautiful collection of early-20th-century homes. Bordered by Butler University, Meridian Street, and the Central Canal, the neighborhood offers a rare blend of academic energy, quiet residential charm, and architectural diversity.

Homes here range from classic Tudor Revivals and English cottages to Colonial homes, brick Bungalows, and thoughtfully updated mid-century designs. Many properties sit on deep lots with mature landscaping, creating a sense of warmth and continuity throughout the neighborhood. Architectural detail is a defining feature — from original hardwoods and arched doorways to limestone exteriors, leaded glass, and slate roofs.

Butler-Tarkington appeals to those who appreciate character homes, community-oriented living, and access to some of Indianapolis’ most desirable amenities. The neighborhood offers proximity to the shops and restaurants along Illinois Street, Holcomb Gardens, the Newfields campus, Broad Ripple Village, and the Monon Trail. Its walkability, established tree canopy, and central location make it one of the northside’s most enduringly popular residential areas.

Why Work With Kris in Butler-Tarkington

Character homes require specialized expertise — especially in a neighborhood where renovation quality, preservation of architectural features, and micro-location can significantly influence value. With her background in high-value appraisal and her focus on historic and architecturally significant homes, Kris Bashenow provides the nuanced insight needed to navigate the Butler-Tarkington market with confidence.

Kris helps buyers evaluate craftsmanship, restoration quality, and long-term potential, while guiding sellers on how to present their home’s architecture, updates, and history in a way that attracts high-caliber buyers. Her concierge-level service, valuation knowledge, and design-informed approach make her an exceptional advocate for anyone buying or selling in Butler-Tarkington.